Duration of Status Rule Vacated: What the Final Ruling Means

By The Immigration Compass | Published 2026-11-16

A federal court vacated the DHS rule that would have ended Duration of Status for F-1 and J-1 students. Here is what the November 16 ruling means.

A federal judge in Boston has issued a final ruling against the DHS rule that would have ended Duration of Status (D/S) for F-1 and J-1 students. The rule is gone for now. Whether it stays gone depends on what DHS does next.

Is Duration of Status still in effect?

Yes. F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors are still admitted under Duration of Status, with no fixed end date on the I-94. The rule never took effect. It was scheduled to start on September 15, 2026, and the court postponed it on September 14. On November 16, 2026, the same judge went a step further and vacated it.

Because the court vacated the rule, the D/S regulations that applied before it remain in place unless a court stays or reverses the vacatur on appeal. Our earlier post on the injunction covers the September order.

What the court decided

In a memorandum and order on November 16, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs and denied DHS's cross-motion. He vacated the rule under the Administrative Procedure Act. The order vacates the rule on the ground that it is "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law."

The order relies on the reasoning from the September 14 decision. The court also accepted two arguments the plaintiffs added at summary judgment. DHS did not adequately consider better use of the existing SEVIS reporting system as a less burdensome alternative, and the rule's limits on academic programs are contrary to the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(F)) because they are not reasonably related to the purpose of the F-1 visa.

The rule would have replaced D/S with fixed admission periods of up to four years for F-1 and J-1, plus fixed periods for I (foreign media) status. DHS said it needed the change to address fraud and abuse of student status. In the Federal Register notice, DHS argued that fixed dates would give officers regular points to check whether people are keeping their status. The court was not persuaded that the rule was lawfully justified.

The plaintiffs are NAFSA, the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, the American Federation of Teachers, the Graduate Labor Organization (AFT Local 6516), the UAW, UAW Local 2322, and The NewsGuild-CWA.

Is this the final word?

Not necessarily. The court directed the clerk to enter final judgment, and DHS can appeal it to the First Circuit. As of November 16, no appeal of the final judgment appeared on the docket or on the NAFSA and Presidents' Alliance pages. We also did not find a public DHS or USCIS statement on the ruling.

DHS's existing appeal (First Circuit No. 26-2112, filed September 30) is about the September order, not this one. The November 16 order says that appeal remains pending. On November 3, DHS asked the First Circuit for a 30-day pause in its appeal, and the plaintiffs did not oppose. DHS had argued that a final judgment would likely moot the appeal or allow the appeals to be consolidated. The ruling stays in effect unless a court stays it.

What this means if you're on Duration of Status right now

This is general information, not legal advice. For your own situation, talk to your school's DSO or a licensed immigration attorney.

Does this change anything for transfers, OPT, or CPT?

The rule would have limited the programs students could pursue, including joint degrees, changes in concentration, and programs not at a higher level than one already completed. The court found those limits unlawful, and because the rule is vacated, none of them are in effect. The rules you already follow for transfers, program changes, and OPT are the ones that apply. Our post on CPT, OPT and STEM OPT under the 2026 DHS rule covers the practical training side.

CPT is a separate track. SEVP's broadcast messages on Integral CPT (2608-01 of August 12 and 2608-02 of August 24, 2026) are not part of this case. The November 16 order deals only with the D/S rule. If you're on CPT, your DSO's approval is still what counts, and our post on the SEVP memo explains those messages.

How we got here

DateWhat happened
July 17, 2026DHS publishes the final rule (91 FR 44976), effective September 15
August 18, 2026Plaintiffs file suit in the District of Massachusetts
September 3, 2026Hearing on the request for preliminary relief
September 14, 2026Judge Saylor postpones the rule's effective date
September 30, 2026DHS appeals the September order to the First Circuit (No. 26-2112)
October 30, 2026Both sides file cross-motions for summary judgment
November 2, 2026Summary judgment briefing is complete
November 3, 2026DHS asks the First Circuit to pause its appeal for 30 days; plaintiffs do not oppose
November 16, 2026District court grants summary judgment and vacates the rule

The short version

A federal court vacated the DHS rule that would have ended Duration of Status, and D/S stays in place. DHS can appeal the final judgment, and the ruling stays in effect unless a court stays it. Until your DSO tells you otherwise, nothing about how you maintain F-1 or J-1 status has changed.

Sources

Wondering how this affects your plans?

Let's go through your status and timeline together. Where legal representation is required, clients are referred to independent licensed immigration attorneys.
Connect With a Consultant